Blog post by Augustin Hamilton (Quebec Life Coalition) — Photo: Freepik
On Tuesday, the federal government presented Bill C-41. The goal of this bill is to cancel the addition of people with only mental illnesses to the group of people who can choose euthanasia. This addition would happen on March 17, 2027, if the bill was not presented.
However, the same bill also legalizes advance requests for euthanasia for individuals whose illness could render them incapable of giving consent in the future. Of course, Attorney General Sean Fraser assured that "rigorous measures" would be put in place, such as ensuring that an advance request would not be carried out if the patient refused euthanasia.
Bill C-41 also stipulates that the provinces must enact their own legislation regarding advance directives for them to take effect; the provisions of provincial laws must meet at least the same standards as those of the federal law but may be more stringent.
In effect, the federal bill would create inequalities across Canada — note that in Alberta, advance directives have been banned, while in Quebec they are already permitted despite the Criminal Code — suggesting that the Liberals are deliberately laying the groundwork for their own law to be struck down by the courts, just as Trudeau Sr.’s abortion law was invalidated in the Morgentaler decision because access to abortion varied from one hospital to another.
One might wonder whether the Liberals aren’t actually trying to ensure that their bill doesn’t pass, so that euthanasia based solely on mental illness becomes legal by default in March. In fact, C-41 satisfies no one — neither those who oppose advance directives, nor those who would like them to be available nationwide, nor those who are unhappy that euthanasia cannot be administered to people with mental illness. Just before announcing their new bill, the Liberals had the opportunity to repeal the expansion of euthanasia through Bill C-218, introduced by Conservative MP Tamara Jansen, but they voted against it.
We must demand that the two aspects of Bill C-41, which are unrelated, be separated so they can be addressed individually, rather than being lumped together in a typical Liberal muddle.
In a single year, 6,268 Quebecers were killed by euthanasia. Ask the Quebec government for a moratorium, an independent inquiry and real palliative care everywhere.
Sign the petition (30 seconds)One share does more than many ads: the people you know will read what the mainstream media leaves out.

Showing 1 reaction
Sign in with
Facebook