In 1787, Catherine II sailed down the Dnieper to admire her new conquests. Her favourite, Prince Potemkin, is said to have set up village façades along the riverbanks, peopled with smiling peasants, taken down at night and put up again farther on for the next day's passage. Historians doubt the story. The expression has stuck all the same, because it names something very real: a stage set built to impress, with nothing behind it.
Our governments have their own Potemkin village. They call it “civil society.”
The article continues below ↓
In a single year, 6,268 Quebecers were killed by euthanasia. Ask the Quebec government for a moratorium, an independent inquiry and real palliative care everywhere.
Sign the petition (30 seconds)In May 2024, on the eve of the first March for Life in Quebec City, Le Devoir published an open letter titled “Let us celebrate our rights, let us push back the conservative movements.” Launched by the Fédération du Québec pour le planning des naissances, it was signed by 161 organizations, including public health institutions. State bodies were thus calling for citizens who were about to march peacefully to be “pushed back.” The next day, counter-protesters were waving smoke bombs, and a government minister took part in the counter-protest.
In 2025, activists who had slipped into the procession set off smoke bombs inside it, the march was blocked and diverted several times, and a priest was interrupted in the middle of a prayer. Last October, at the Life Chain, about a hundred counter-protesters surrounded a dozen people praying in silence on a sidewalk of Boulevard Laurier in Quebec City and tore their signs from their hands. The police had to step in twice.

Counter-protesters inside the procession of the March for Life in Quebec City, 2025. Photo: QLC
All of this is presented to us as the spontaneous voice of the people. The people have spoken, we are told. Can't you hear them?
Let us follow the money. Of the 126 signatories of the 2024 letter that are neither unions nor public institutions, at least 86 have received public funds since 2016. The Regroupement des groupes de femmes de la Capitale-Nationale, which organized the 2025 counter-protest, received $458,433 from Ottawa between 2021 and 2024, notably for political advocacy.
This is no isolated case. In a study published by Cardus in October, Étienne-Alexandre Beauregard counts 346 collective-rights advocacy organizations funded by Quebec's “Promotion des droits” stream alone, whose budget grew from $16 to $18 million a year up to 2017-2018 to nearly $41 million in 2024-2025. Across all programs, he estimates this funding at some $120 million in 2023-2024. He found no group classed as right-leaning among the recipients. Of those that publish their financial statements, four out of five draw at least half their revenue from the State. Marie-Hélène Arruda, then coordinator of the Regroupement des organismes en défense collective des droits, put it bluntly: “the organization must criticize the government so that the government will fund it.” Ottawa does the same on its side, notably with the $100 million of its federal 2SLGBTQI+ action plan.
Some will object that the State gives no one any orders. It funds independent organizations; what they do with their freedom is their own business.
In 1170, Henry II of England, exasperated with Archbishop Thomas Becket, is said to have cried out before his court: “Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?” He had given no order. Yet four knights understood what would please the king and murdered Becket in his cathedral. Four years later, Henry did penance barefoot at his tomb, because everyone, himself included, knew where the responsibility lay.
Subsidized groups need no written orders. They know which causes keep the grants coming and which voices are unwelcome. No government would yet dare send its own agents to surround people praying on a sidewalk. It has no need to: it is enough to subsidize those who will do it, and then speak of a spontaneous movement.
There is an almost comic paradox here. These groups present themselves as rebels fighting power and “the system.” Yet it is power that signs their cheques. No truly independent movement wants to depend on the authority it claims to challenge. A group that lives on public funds and mobilizes on cue against anyone who questions the government's direction does not challenge the status quo: it is its security detail. And so the loop closes. Elected officials who want to advance certain causes, such as wider access to abortion or 2SLGBTQI+ programs, fund the groups that will demand new measures and new budgets to that end, then answer their demands by presenting themselves as the humble servants of the popular will.
What we get is less a civil society than an immune system: as soon as an element foreign to the official consensus appears, the antibodies converge to isolate it before it can grow.
Let me be clear. I do not fault the State for supporting civil society. I fault it for funding groups that intimidate and silence peaceful citizens, while taking care never to be associated with what is done with its money. Let the reader try reversing the roles: would he accept public funds being used to surround a feminist vigil and tear away its signs?
Real civil society pays its own way: families, communities of faith, volunteers, ordinary donors. The organization I lead does not receive a cent from any government. That society is slower and poorer than the other, but it is real, and that is precisely why it bothers those who prefer painted façades.
Quebec's new government wants, according to the office of the President of the Treasury Board, “to make sure every dollar is well spent.” It could start here. A government confident in its legitimacy has no need of a paid chorus to know what the people think. If it wants to hear them, it need only stop paying someone to drown out the voice of its citizens.
Georges Buscemi, President of Quebec Life Coalition
One share does more than many ads: the people you know will read what the mainstream media leaves out.

Showing 1 reaction
Sign in with
Facebook